Transport Evolved BMW i8 Spyder Concept 36

Report: BMW i5 Electric Car On The Way, Will Come With Optional Range-Extender, Says BMW i-Chief

Ever since BMW launched its i3 electric car, i3 REx range-extended electric car and i8 plug-in hybrid sports car back in 2013, the automotive world has been asking a pretty simple question of the German automaker: what will BMW’s next i-brand electric car be like?

For the past few years, we’ve heard plenty of different rumors that all tried to answer that question. Most agree the next BMW i-branded plug-in will be known as the BMW i5, but that’s where the similarities stop. From a mid-sized SUV to a luxury sedan and even a city car built on an extended version of the BMW i3’s lightweight chassis, we’ve heard all the i5 rumors there are.

The BMW i3 has proven very popular. Now BMW wants a more family-friendly EV.

The BMW i3 has proven very popular. Now BMW wants a more family-friendly EV.

But earlier this week, Car and Driver lay claim to some of the most concrete news about the BMW i5 we’ve heard to date, straight from the mouth of BMW i-brand boss Henrik Wenders.

Wenders, whose official title is BMW i Head of Product, gave an exclusive interview to the publication in which he painted the BMW i5 as a car designed to be the principal car of a multi-car family, with enough range to tackle everyday driving with ease and an optional range-extender similar to the one found in the BMW i3 REx.

Final specs of the BMW i5 are yet to be announced, but it will include optional range-extender.

Final specs of the BMW i5 are yet to be announced, but it will include optional range-extender.

Despite the presence of an optional gasoline range-extending engine however, Wenders was keen to reiterate that the BMW i5 won’t be a plug-in hybrid like the BMW i8 (or to that matter, any of BMW’s mainstream plug-in hybrid models). For the i5, electricity will be the primary fuel choice. In addition to cementing BMW’s commitment to electric drive, the news puts to bed the rumor that the BMW i5 was to be a plug-in hybrid with electric assist, a fact that we’re guessing will make a lot of BMWs i3 fans very happy indeed.

“The range-extender plays an important part in the next years when range remains a limiting factor and a source of anxiety,” Wenders told Car and Driver. “Of course, once we get to a range that is more comparable with that of an internal-combustion engine it will become obsolete. So this is the reason I can say we will continue to offer the range-extender in the future as optional equipment, to address different customer needs.”

Like the BMW i3 however, BMW expects the range-extending option to slowly fall out of favor as more and more customers realize the true potential and versatility of an electric car. When the BMW i3 launched, the BMW i3 REx was offered as something of a ‘comfort blanket’ to customers, offering the reassurance that misjudging the range of the car’s battery pack wouldn’t necessarily result in being stranded. But it’s worth noting that while the range-extender gives customers that reassurance, it often ends up never being used. Ironically, those with range-extended versions of the i3 are more likely to push their cars to their all-electric limits and as a consequence, learn where their car’s all-electric limits really lie. Those drivers end up driving further between charges, but not actually needing the range extender.

To date, only a tiny proportion of BMW i3 REx owners even use the gasoline engine.

To date, only a tiny proportion of BMW i3 REx owners even use the gasoline engine.

“At the beginning of the i3, the [take rate of the] range-extender was much more than we expected,” Wenders said. “More than 60 percent. It’s decreasing dramatically now and what we’re seeing is that people are almost never using it and that it was purely a psychological thing; it is being regularly used in fewer than five percent of i3s.”

As to the car’s role? While the BMW i8 captures supercar aspirations and the BMW i3 provides urbanites a way to get around town with minimal fuss, Wenders told Car and Driver that the BMW i5 will be built with a more mainstream market in mind. Neither the BMW i8 nor BMW i3 are particularly family-friendly, and Wenders says BMW will address that with the i5.

“We are thinking of a new i model above it to attract families, and that means it must be capable of being the first car in the household. We are still working very hard on the usage concept, but this needs to be defined by the market and not by us,” Wenders explained. “We are a sub-brand, part of the most successful premium carmaker in the world. We want to continue that story. We have the opportunity to be the spearhead, we can test new materials, new design languages, new body concepts. Innovation is our strength.”

When it came to discussing range or performance, Wenders was coy about specifics. But as a sub-brand of BMW, he hinted that whatever BMW ultimately chose to do, it would be in keeping with both the BMW i-brand thus far and the BMW brand as a whole. For the most part, that means a car with decent performance, attention to detail, and premium feel.

The Chevrolet Bolt EV will play a part in shaping the i5's specs -- but the Tesla Model 3 will be its competitor.

The Chevrolet Bolt EV will play a part in shaping the i5’s specs — but the Tesla Model 3 will be its competitor.

The lack of indication of range is, we’ll admit, frustrating. But with the BMW i5 generally expected to enter into the market in the next few years, we’d suggest a range in excess of 200 miles will be essential for the brand to continue to grow given the impending launch of the 200+ mile Chevrolet Bolt EV and the as-yet unrevealed Tesla Model 3. The former may not be a direct competitor to the luxury marque in terms of size or performance, but it does mark the start of a brand-new wave of affordable longer-range electric cars that BMW will have to equal or preferably best across its lineup in order to stay relevant. Its price point, while something BMW will not have to match, will set expectations among consumers over how much a long-range battery pack should cost moving forward.

As to the Model 3? That’s a car that BMW will have to match in terms of performance, price and specification. With a predicted pre-incentive price tag of $35,000, the Tesla Model 3 is expected to sit squarely in the middle of BMW’s 3-series territory. And that probably means it will also cross-shop extremely aggressively against BMW’s next i-brand car.

Will BMW’s i5 be a successful addition to the BMW i-brand family? What features will it need in order to make an impact in the electric car marketplace? And what price would you pay for a family-friendly all-electric BMW with moderate range capabilities?

Leave your thoughts in the comments below.


Want to keep up with the latest news in evolving transport? Don’t forget to follow Transport Evolved on Twitter, like us on Facebook and G+, and subscribe to our YouTube channel.

You can also support us directly as a monthly supporting member by visiting

Share on FacebookTweet about this on TwitterShare on Google+Share on LinkedInDigg thisShare on RedditEmail this to someonePin on Pinterest

Related News

  • vdiv

    Dear BMW,
    At some point, sooner than later, you will have to take the training wheels off and go all-electric. It’s not that scary, it’s actually a lot of fun, just ask ElectraGirl!
    A well-wisher

    • Outcast_Searcher

      What are you talking about? The i8 is a pure EV. The i3 base model is a pure EV. The I5 will (apparently) run in EV mode like the I3, unless the customer want/needs REx mode. If you expect a family-friendly car today to meet the typical family’s needs with a small range like the 2016 i3 base model (range 81 miles — in good conditions), that’s pretty unrealistic.

      Making the imperfect the enemy of the good isn’t very practical. That’s why BMW (per this article) is saying the REx mode is a bridge until its EV’s don’t need it. That’s not the Tesla plan, but it doesn’t make it an invalid plan. As a consumer, I want real choices from several car companies.

      • vdiv

        Guess what, EVs don’t need it.

  • CDspeed

    I am very disappointed in BMW, they’ve been one of my top favorite brands, I always test drive, and I still find their cars very compelling. So I stayed with BMW when going electric, but in the time following the debut of BMWi their electric efforts have actually declined. It’s seems now like the i3 BEV only exists so they can say they build electric cars, and then everything else wearing the i or eDrive badge is a gas burning hybrid (i3 REx included). I am now preparing to jump on the Tesla Model X waiting list for a X 90D.

    • Outcast_Searcher

      With respect, that makes no sense for the i3. First, the base car has no range extender at all — it’s a pure BEV. Second, the range extender option is NOT a hybrid design — it merely uses gasoline to charge the battery. Until BMW can come up with batteries large and efficient enough to offer a real-world 200(+) mile range like Tesla, it’s letting customers have access to an EV for their daily local driving, and a more “realistic” range if they go out of town.

      So calling the i3 REx a hybrid is inaccurate. You could drive for years without burning any gas, unless there is some needed running in REx mode on occasion for a maintenance issue, such as burning old gas or running the charging motor on occasion.

      Don’t get me wrong. I’m not saying the i3 is a great car. I think like all electrics at this point, you don’t get that much bang for the buck (Tesla may change this with the Model 3 — the proof will be in the pudding). I find the 2016 base model’s 81 mile range completely unacceptable. (No way do I want to have to rent a car to take a trip only one hour away. The range extender would fix that, but I’m not at ALL fond of having to buy another motor and a gas tank to haul around in EV mode or of the significant boost in price).

      • CDspeed

        I’ve driven my i3 over 200 miles in a day, and I don’t have the REx, you don’t need to rent a car for an hours drive, just know where your CCS chargers are, and if you can charge at your destinations. I know calling the REx version a hybrid isn’t entirely accurate from a powertrain stand point, but you are still in a car with two onboard fuel sources 1) stored electricity 2) gasoline. And even though the REx isn’t connected to the wheels you are carrying both an electric motor, and an ICE. So it could be called a hybrid because it’s still using two fuels, and two motors, pure electric cars, and pure gas or diesel cars use one fuel source, and one type of motor.

Content Copyright (c) 2016 Transport Evolved LLC